Best Pizza Spots in Staten Island: A Slice Lover’s Guide

Staten Island might be New York City’s best-kept pizza secret. While Manhattan and Brooklyn often steal the spotlight, the “Forgotten Borough” is home to some of the most mouthwatering pies you’ll ever taste. Whether you’re a fan of classic New York slices, crave a hearty Sicilian, or love trying inventive toppings, Staten Island has something for every pizza lover. Let’s embark on a cheesy journey through some of the best pizza spots across the island!

Joe & Pat’s: The Thin-Crust Legend

Ask any Staten Islander about their go-to pizza, and Joe & Pat’s is bound to come up. Open since 1960, this family-run pizzeria is famous for its ultra-thin, crispy crust and perfectly balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio. Their signature vodka pie is a must-try—creamy, tangy, and utterly addictive. The cozy, retro vibe makes every visit feel like a trip back in time.

Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern: A Staple for Generations

Denino’s is more than a pizza joint—it’s a Staten Island institution. Located in Port Richmond, this spot has been serving up legendary pies since 1937. Their sausage and onion pizza is the stuff of local legend, and the bustling, family-friendly atmosphere makes it a perfect place for gatherings. Don’t forget to try their fried calamari as a starter!

Lenny’s Creations: Sicilian Perfection

If you’re a fan of thick, pillowy Sicilian slices, Lenny’s Creations is your paradise. Their squares are light yet satisfyingly rich, with a crispy base and gooey cheese that stretches for miles. Locals rave about the grandma slice, topped with fresh basil and a tangy tomato sauce.

Lee’s Tavern: Bar Pie Bliss

Lee’s Tavern may look unassuming from the outside, but inside, you’ll find some of the best bar pies in the city. Their thin, cracker-like crust is the perfect canvas for classic toppings like pepperoni or mushrooms. The laid-back tavern feel and friendly staff make it a favorite for both locals and visitors alike.

Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza: For the Adventurous Eater

Craving something a little different? Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza is known for its creative pies and smoky, wood-fired flavor. Their “Pizza Alla Vodka” won the World’s Best Pizza title, and their “Smokin’ Goodfella” with smoked mozzarella and roasted peppers is a flavor bomb. Don’t be afraid to branch out and try something new here!

Final Thoughts: Staten Island’s Pizza Pride

From old-school classics to innovative newcomers, Staten Island’s pizza scene is bursting with flavor and personality. Next time you’re craving a slice, skip the ferry to Manhattan and explore the borough’s own cheesy treasures. Your taste buds will thank you!

🍕 What’s your favorite Staten Island pizza spot? Share your top picks and best slice stories in the comments below!