The Best Whiskey Bars in Brooklyn Heights

Brooklyn Heights isn’t just about brownstones and stunning skyline views—it’s also a hidden haven for whiskey lovers. Whether you’re a seasoned sipper hunting for rare single malts or just looking for a cozy spot to enjoy a classic Old Fashioned, this neighborhood has something special on tap. Let’s dive deeper into the best whiskey bars in Brooklyn Heights, each with its own unique charm and story.

The Long Island Bar: Where History Meets Hospitality

Perched on the corner of Atlantic and Henry, The Long Island Bar is a slice of Brooklyn history. Open since the 1950s and lovingly restored by its current owners, the bar glows with neon lights and retro décor. The whiskey list is both approachable and impressive, featuring American bourbons like Pappy Van Winkle (when available), smooth Irish whiskeys, and a rotating selection of Japanese and Scotch bottles. The bartenders here are true professionals—don’t hesitate to ask for a recommendation based on your taste. Their Old Fashioned is legendary, but if you’re in the mood for something adventurous, try the Penicillin, a smoky-sweet cocktail that showcases the complexity of peated Scotch.

Henry Public: A Step Back in Time

Walking into Henry Public feels like entering a sepia-toned photograph. The wood-paneled walls, vintage fixtures, and candlelit tables set the mood for a relaxing evening. Their whiskey menu is a love letter to American distilling, with a focus on rye and bourbon. Try a pour of WhistlePig or a local Brooklyn Distilling Co. rye. Henry Public is also famous for its creative cocktails—think a Maple Leaf (bourbon, maple syrup, lemon) or a classic Sazerac. And don’t leave without trying their house-smoked turkey leg sandwich, which pairs beautifully with a spicy rye.

Custom House: The Neighborhood’s Living Room

If you’re after a laid-back vibe, Custom House is your go-to. This Irish-inspired pub is beloved by locals for its friendly staff, hearty food, and surprisingly deep whiskey selection. Here, you’ll find classics like Jameson and Redbreast alongside American craft whiskeys and a few rare finds from Scotland and Japan. The bar regularly hosts whiskey tastings and live music nights, making it a lively spot to explore new flavors and meet fellow enthusiasts. Ask for a whiskey flight to sample a range of styles, or let the bartender surprise you with their personal favorite.

Clover Club: Cocktails, Craft, and Class

Just over the border in Cobble Hill, but well worth the walk, Clover Club is a cocktail institution. The ambiance is vintage-chic, with plush banquettes and a marble bar. Their whiskey program is world-class, featuring everything from small-batch bourbons to rare Scotch single malts. If you’re a cocktail fan, don’t miss their signature whiskey sour—bright, balanced, and topped with a silky egg white foam. The bartenders are true artists, happy to customize drinks or introduce you to something new. Pair your drink with their crispy deviled eggs or the house charcuterie for a perfect night out.

More Hidden Gems

• Jack the Horse Tavern: Known for its cozy fireplace and intimate vibe, this spot offers a curated whiskey list and excellent bar snacks. Try their Manhattan, made with locally sourced rye.
• Montero’s Bar & Grill: A classic dive with nautical décor, Montero’s might surprise you with its selection of affordable whiskeys and no-frills cocktails. It’s the perfect place to end the night with friends.

Tips for Whiskey Lovers in Brooklyn Heights

• Explore Tasting Flights: Many bars offer flights that let you compare whiskeys from different regions or styles. It’s a fun, educational way to discover your preferences.
• Chat with the Bartenders: Don’t be shy—they love sharing their knowledge and might introduce you to a new favorite bottle or cocktail.
• Pair with Food: From rich cheeses to smoked meats, the right snack can elevate your whiskey experience. Many bars offer small plates designed to complement their drink menus.
• Visit During Off-Peak Hours: For a more intimate experience, try visiting early in the evening or on a weekday. You’ll have more time to chat, taste, and savor each sip.

Brooklyn Heights’ whiskey bars are more than just places to drink—they’re community hubs, each with its own stories and regulars. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just unwinding after work, you’ll find a warm welcome and a perfect pour waiting for you. So next time you’re in the neighborhood, raise your glass to Brooklyn’s best-kept whiskey secrets. Cheers!